Small European Film Markets: Portraits and Comparisons
Comparison with Larger Markets / The effects of US films on local industries
The effects of US films on local industries
By Ana Falcon
This section examines the penetration of US content in the CresCine and large markets, highlighting areas where US films have a competitive advantage compared to European content (see Methodology: Comparison with larger markets).
1. Overview
US films traditionally have a significant presence at box offices in the European markets. Typically, a European blockbuster or high-grossing film is recognized as such in just 1.2 European markets on average, compared to a US blockbuster, which is successful in 6.7 European markets, a disparity often attributed to US blockbusters being based on well-known international franchises or ‘brands’, as opposed to the locally embedded content of European blockbusters (EAO, 2023). In 2022, almost 70% of admissions to European films stemmed from low-grossing and mid-tier films (EAO, 2023).
There is a considerable presence of US audiovisual productions in CresCine markets (see: Admissions and market shares) and the large markets analysed. According to the CNC, in 2022 US studio films generated most of the cinema admissions in France (53.1%), Spain (74.5%), UK and Ireland (88.4%), Germany (72.3%), and Italy (68.5%). The substantial representation of US audiovisual works (both films and series) is also visible in VoD services (Greece, 2022). In 2022, US works took the lion’s share with 49% of all works in VoD catalogues compared to 32% works of European origin (EAO, 2023). In addition, one third of all SVoD (38%) and TVoD (34%) services in Europe belong to a US company (EAO, 2023).
Production budgets of US films surpass the average budget of films made in the CresCine markets. In 2020, the average budget of a fiction film in large European markets amounted to €2.7 million; in medium-sized markets, the average feature budget was €1.6 million; and in small European markets, the median budget for a fiction film was €1.2 million (Fioroni, 2024). In 2021, of all 943 US features produced, 23.9% had budgets over €13.6 million, 49.8% films had production costs between €0.9 million and €13.5 million, while 26.1% had budgets below €0.9 million (MPAA, 2022). According to Kuehn and Lampe (2023), US low-budget films have an average budget of €8.9 million, with mid-budget and high-budget films made in the same country having an average production cost of €42 million and €141 million respectively.
The European Audiovisual Observatory reports that the US audiovisual sector value is worth approximately €180 billion, in contrast to Europe’s €120 billion (with EU27 countries accounting for €88 billion of this figure) (EAO, 2023). Comparing the US audiovisual sector to some of the large European markets denotes considerable differences in magnitude. For example, the value of the audiovisual sector of the two largest markets, Germany and the UK, is €23 billion and €22 billion, respectively. This reflects the expenditure per capita on audiovisual content, as US and Japanese citizens still spend more (directly and indirectly through advertising and public funding) than Europeans, with the UK being an exception (EAO, 2023).
2. Majority of US films based on pre-existing IP
According to our analysis, among the top 100 US films by admissions within the CresCine and in the large markets, 13 were standalone films, while 87 were based on existing IP that break down as follows: 55 sequels, 16 new adaptations, 12 remakes, and 4 prequels. Admissions to these 100 films accounted for nearly 49% of all US film admissions in these countries between 2014 and 2022.
3. Most popular genres of US films
The most popular genre according to the total volume of admissions in the 13 markets was ‘Adventure/Action/Science Fiction’ (40.4% of all admissions). Looking at the total admissions of US films in this genre, the highest share was secured in the UK (29.4%), France (20.7%), and Germany (14.8%). The highest share of admissions for the ‘Animation for Children’ genre was achieved in the UK (22.9%), France (20.9%) and 14.8% (Germany). Among the genres, comedy had the lowest share of admissions throughout the period analysed. Drama, which is the most popular genre in CresCine films (see: Top performing films) and films exported from the European large markets (see: Genre mix of exported films from large markets), accounted for a modest 6.6% of admissions of the top 100 US films.
Regarding the distribution of other genres in the top 100 US films in CresCine and Large Markets, musicals had a higher share of admissions in the UK, compared to the other countries, representing 5.38% of all admissions. In Portugal, ‘Adventure/Action’ films generated 9.98% of cinema admissions. Drama was more popular in Italy and Denmark, compared to other countries, accounting for 9.54% and 9.21% of domestic admissions, respectively. Comedy was the least popular genre in general, with its biggest market share compared to other countries being Croatia, where it represents 1.25% of admissions.